Woman comparing paint samples in living room

Benjamin Moore Vs. Sherwin-Williams: Which is Best For Your Home

Request Your Free Estimate Today

GET A FREE ESTIMATE →

For most Canadian homeowners, the practical answer is this: choose Benjamin Moore for colour-critical interiors, trim, and cabinetry, and choose Sherwin-Williams when exterior durability, store access, or sale pricing drives the decision. Mixing both on the same project is not only acceptable — it is what many experienced contractors do.

Here are the decisive tradeoffs at a glance:

  • Coverage and hide: Benjamin Moore Aura and Regal Select tend to offer deeper pigment and better one-coat hide on saturated colours, while Sherwin-Williams Emerald is engineered for smooth flow and consistent levelling.
  • Durability and washability: Sherwin-Williams Duration and Emerald are the go-to lines for high-traffic rooms, mudrooms, and exterior surfaces where scrubbability matters most.
  • Canadian availability and pricing: Sherwin-Williams has a wider company-owned store network across Canada and runs promotions with significant discounts several times a year. Benjamin Moore is sold through independent dealers and select hardware stores, with less frequent discounting.

Pro Tip: On a whole-house project, buy Benjamin Moore Advance for trim and cabinetry, and time your Sherwin-Williams wall paint purchase around a major sale. You get the best of both lines without paying full price on everything.

Table of Contents

Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams: product lines compared

The four lines that matter most for Canadian residential projects are Benjamin Moore Aura, Benjamin Moore Regal Select, Sherwin-Williams Emerald, and Sherwin-Williams Duration. Here is how they stack up regarding the dimensions that actually drive decisions.

Hands comparing paint cans at workshop table

Product Line Best for / Use case Relative price (Canada) Coverage / hide Durability & washability VOC profile Colour range Where to buy in Canada Finish options
BM Aura Colour-critical interiors, accent walls, deep colours Highest (premium tier pricing) approximate Excellent; high solids, strong one-coat hide Very good; not the top scrub rating Low-VOC ~3,500 colours Independent BM dealers, select hardware stores Flat, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss
BM Regal Select Everyday interiors, bedrooms, living rooms Mid-high (mid-to-high tier pricing) approximate Good; reliable hide in 2 coats Good; suitable for moderate traffic Low-VOC ~3,500 colours Independent BM dealers, select hardware stores Flat, eggshell, pearl, semi-gloss
SW Emerald Walls, trim, high-traffic rooms, colour changes Mid-high (mid-to-high tier pricing) approximate Very good; excellent self-levelling Excellent; top scrub resistance Low-VOC ~1,700 colours SW company stores, some big-box retailers Flat, matte, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss
SW Duration Exterior siding, high-traffic interiors, freeze-thaw climates Mid (mid-tier pricing) approximate Good; two coats typical Excellent; specified for freeze-thaw Low-VOC ~1,700 colours SW company stores, pro outlets Flat, satin, gloss

Note: Canadian retail prices reflect dealer and provincial markups and will differ from US list prices. Treat the figures above as relative tiers rather than exact Canadian dollar amounts.

Infographic comparing Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams

Pro Tip: Use Benjamin Moore for cabinets and trim where colour accuracy and a hard finish matter, and buy Sherwin-Williams Emerald for walls during a sale event. The two brands’ tinting systems are independent, so confirm your colour codes at each counter separately.

How do pigment, solids, and formula affect real-world coverage?

The difference between these two brands is not just marketing. Benjamin Moore tends to have higher solids content, which generally translates into better hide and colour depth, particularly on deep or saturated shades. In practice, Aura can often cover a dramatic colour change in one coat where a competing formula needs two. That matters on a weekend DIY timeline.

Painter applying paint test samples on board

Sherwin-Williams Emerald takes a different approach. It is engineered for flow and self-levelling, which means it is more forgiving on walls if you are not an experienced roller. Brush marks and lap lines are less visible, and the finish tends to look more uniform for less-skilled applicators. For a homeowner painting a large living room for the first time, that workability advantage is real.

Higher solids content also means Benjamin Moore’s formula is thicker. On flat or low-sheen finishes, that thickness rewards a slow, deliberate roller technique. Rush it, and you can see stipple texture in the dried film. Emerald’s thinner, more fluid body is more forgiving at speed.

Statistic callout: Consumer Reports testing consistently shows that performance is line-dependent — premium lines from either brand outperform mid-tier formulations from the same manufacturer. Choosing Aura over Regal Select, or Emerald over a builder-grade SW line, makes a larger difference than choosing between the two brands at the same tier.

Realistic coverage for both premium lines runs roughly 350–400 sq ft per US gallon (approximately 8.5–9.5 m² per litre) on smooth, primed surfaces. On textured walls or when covering a dark colour with a lighter one, plan for two coats regardless of brand.

Pro Tip: Before committing to a full room, paint a 30 cm × 30 cm test patch on the actual wall and let it cure for 24 hours. Canadian light conditions — especially north-facing rooms with cool daylight — can shift undertones dramatically from what you saw on the chip at the store.

Which product line should you use for each room?

Choosing a brand wholesale is the wrong approach. The right call is matching the product line to the job.

  1. Bedrooms and colour-critical living rooms: Benjamin Moore Aura or Regal Select. The pigment depth and colour accuracy justify the price when the colour is the centrepiece of the room.
  2. Kitchens and mudrooms: Sherwin-Williams Emerald in a satin or semi-gloss finish. The scrub resistance and moisture tolerance make it the practical choice where walls take daily abuse.
  3. Bathrooms: Either Emerald or Aura in semi-gloss or satin. Both perform well in humidity; the deciding factor is usually which colour you need. BM’s broader palette of ~3,500 colours gives more options for precise colour matching.
  4. Trim and interior doors: Benjamin Moore Advance. This waterborne alkyd produces a hard, lacquer-like finish that takes up to 30 days to reach full cure, but the result is a durable, washable surface that holds up to door frames and baseboards. For interior door colour and sheen guidance, sheen selection matters as much as the product line.
  5. Cabinets: Benjamin Moore Advance again. The hardness and levelling of this formula are why professional cabinet painters specify it almost universally. Allow the full cure window before loading shelves or closing drawers repeatedly.
  6. Exterior siding: Sherwin-Williams Duration for most Canadian climates. It is specifically formulated for freeze-thaw durability, which matters in Ontario winters. Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior is the better call when colour retention on deep or dark shades is the priority — it carries a Lifetime Limited Warranty on many substrates per manufacturer claims.

Drying vs curing — a scheduling note: Most premium lines are dry to the touch in 1–2 hours and ready for a second coat in 4–6 hours. Full cure, however, takes much longer. Benjamin Moore Advance needs up to 30 days before the surface can handle heavy use. Plan cabinet and trim projects accordingly, and avoid scrubbing freshly painted surfaces even when they feel hard.

Warranty note: Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior and Sherwin-Williams Duration both carry manufacturer warranties, but terms vary by substrate and application conditions. Confirm warranty details with your local dealer before purchase, as Canadian market terms may differ from US literature.

How does pricing and availability work in Canada?

Paint pricing in Canada is not straightforward. Provincial distribution, dealer markups, and promotional timing can move the effective price by 15–30% compared to US list prices. The relative tiers hold — Aura and Emerald sit at the premium end, Regal Select and Duration in the mid-high range — but the absolute dollar amounts vary by region and retailer.

The most important pricing factor for Sherwin-Williams buyers is the promotional calendar. SW runs store-wide discounts of 30–40% off several times a year, including major events around Labour Day and other seasonal windows. During those sales, Emerald drops into a price bracket that makes it genuinely competitive with mid-tier Benjamin Moore lines at full price. Benjamin Moore discounts are less aggressive and less frequent, so timing matters less for BM purchases.

Two practical scenarios for Canadian buyers:

  • Trim-only project: If you are painting trim and cabinets only, buy Benjamin Moore Advance at full price. The volume is low, the finish quality difference is significant, and no SW promotion will change the calculus enough to matter.
  • Full-house repaint: For walls across an entire home, the volume of paint needed makes the SW promotional discount very significant. Waiting for a 40% off event to buy Emerald for the walls — while using BM Advance for trim — is the approach many contractors and experienced DIYers use in Durham Region.

Where to buy in Canada:

  • Benjamin Moore: Independent paint dealers, select Home Hardware locations, and Benjamin Moore boutique stores. Availability varies by community; smaller towns may have one dealer or none.
  • Sherwin-Williams: Company-owned SW stores are present in most mid-size and large Canadian cities. Some big-box retailers carry SW lines depending on region.

Pro Tip: Sign up for Sherwin-Williams email alerts to catch sale announcements before they go public. For Benjamin Moore, ask your local dealer about contractor pricing — some dealers extend a modest discount on larger orders even without a trade account.

Durability, washability, and VOC levels for Canadian homes

Scrub ratings and high-traffic performance

For rooms where walls take regular cleaning — kitchens, hallways, children’s rooms — scrub resistance is the spec that matters most. Sherwin-Williams Emerald and Duration lead here. Both are formulated for high washability, and Emerald in particular is frequently specified by contractors for family homes where walls need to handle everything from crayon marks to cooking splatter.

Benjamin Moore Aura is very good, but its strength is colour depth rather than raw scrubbability. Regal Select is solid for moderate-traffic rooms. For a mudroom or a kitchen that gets wiped down weekly, Emerald or Duration is the more practical choice.

  • High-traffic rooms (kitchens, mudrooms, hallways): Sherwin-Williams Emerald or Duration in satin or semi-gloss.
  • Moderate-traffic rooms (bedrooms, living rooms): Benjamin Moore Aura or Regal Select in eggshell or pearl.
  • Humid rooms (bathrooms): Either brand in semi-gloss or satin; confirm the line is rated for moisture resistance.
  • Exterior surfaces: Sherwin-Williams Duration for freeze-thaw climates; Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior for colour-critical or dark-shade applications.

VOC levels and indoor air quality

VOC (volatile organic compound) levels matter in Canadian homes, particularly in winter when ventilation is limited. Canada’s federal VOC regulations for architectural coatings are set under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, which establishes maximum allowable VOC concentrations by product category.

Statistic callout: The EPA classifies low-VOC paints as those containing less than 50 g/L of VOCs for flat finishes and less than 150 g/L for non-flat finishes. Most premium lines from both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams fall well within these thresholds.

Both brands offer low-VOC options across their premium lines. Benjamin Moore’s Natura line has historically been positioned as a zero-VOC product, and Green Seal certification is one of the most reliable third-party benchmarks to look for when VOC levels are a priority. Sherwin-Williams also offers low-VOC formulations within Emerald and other lines.

In practical terms, even low-VOC paints benefit from ventilation during and after application. In a Canadian winter, open windows for at least 2–4 hours after painting and run a ventilation fan where possible. Airing times are longer in cold weather because lower temperatures slow off-gassing.

For maintenance, both brands’ premium lines clean well with a damp cloth and mild soap. Avoid abrasive cleaners on flat or matte finishes regardless of brand — they will dull the sheen. Satin and semi-gloss hold up to more aggressive cleaning, which is why those sheens are recommended for kitchens and bathrooms.

How LA Rocks Renovations chooses paint on Durham Region jobs

At LA Rocks Renovations, the team handles interior painting, exterior painting, trim and cabinetry work, and full-house repaints across Bowmanville, Clarington, and the broader Durham Region. The brand choice on any given job comes down to the specific surface, the client’s colour goals, and what is practical to source and schedule locally.

On cabinet and trim projects, Benjamin Moore Advance is the standard specification. The cure time requires planning — doors and drawers need to be left open or removed for the first few weeks — but the finished surface is hard and cleanable in a way that latex-only formulas cannot match.

Colour matching workflow matters too. When a client brings a chip from one brand and wants it matched in another, the team uses spectrophotometer matching at the counter. It works reliably for most colours, but very deep or complex custom shades can drift slightly between tinting systems. For those cases, sticking with the original brand’s formula is the safer call.

Pro Tip: If you are hiring a contractor for interior painting in Durham Region, ask them to specify the product line by name on the quote — not just “premium paint.” Knowing whether you are getting Aura, Regal Select, Emerald, or Duration tells you exactly what you are paying for.

[]

How to choose the right paint for your project

Work through these questions before you buy a single litre.

  1. What is the room’s function? High-traffic or high-moisture rooms need Emerald or Duration. Colour-critical or low-traffic rooms are where Aura and Regal Select shine.
  2. How important is colour accuracy? If you have a specific colour in mind and it is in Benjamin Moore’s palette, buy it there. The pigment system is optimized for their own colours.
  3. What is your timeline? If you need to use the room within a week, avoid Benjamin Moore Advance for trim — the cure time will not be complete. Use a standard latex trim paint instead and accept a slightly softer finish.
  4. What is your budget, and can you wait for a sale? If you can time your wall paint purchase to a Sherwin-Williams promotion, the savings on a full-house repaint are meaningful. If you need paint this weekend, buy what is available at the best quality tier you can afford.
  5. Is this interior or exterior? Exterior projects in Canada need a product rated for freeze-thaw cycling. Duration is the default; Aura Exterior is the upgrade for dark colours.

Questions to ask at the paint counter:

  • What is the recommended number of coats for this colour over my existing wall colour?
  • What is the recoat window and full cure time for this product?
  • Does this line carry a manufacturer warranty, and what are the conditions?
  • What is your return policy on tinted paint?
  • Do you have sample pots available for this colour?

Red flags when buying:

  • A dealer who cannot confirm the tint code or match a specified colour formula.
  • A premium-line price that seems unusually low outside of a known sale event — it may be a discontinued batch or a substitution.
  • Stock shortages that push a substitution to a lower product tier without disclosing it.

Paint store checklist:

  1. Buy a sample pot (or the smallest available size) and test on the actual wall.
  2. Let the sample cure for 24 hours before judging colour and sheen.
  3. Confirm the number of coats recommended for your specific colour and substrate.
  4. Order 10% extra for touch-ups and keep the lid sealed in a temperature-controlled space.
  5. Note the tint formula on the can label — you will need it for future touch-ups.

For interior door colour choices, the same sampling principle applies: test the colour on the door in the room’s actual light before committing to a full litre.

Pro Tip: Take a photo of the tint formula sticker on every can before you open it. If the label gets damaged or the can is lost, that formula is the only way to get an exact match later.

Key takeaways

Benjamin Moore is the stronger choice for colour-critical interiors and trim, while Sherwin-Williams leads on scrub resistance, exterior durability, and value when purchased during a sale.

Point Details
Match line to job, not brand to brand Premium lines from either brand outperform mid-tier lines; pick Aura or Emerald over a builder-grade option every time.
BM for trim and colour; SW for walls and exteriors Use Benjamin Moore Advance for cabinets and trim; use Sherwin-Williams Emerald or Duration for walls, high-traffic rooms, and exterior siding.
Time SW purchases around sales Sherwin-Williams runs 30–40% off promotions several times a year; buying Emerald on sale makes it highly competitive with Benjamin Moore at full price.
Always sample in your home’s light Paint a test patch and let it cure 24 hours before committing — Canadian light conditions shift undertones significantly from store chips.
LA Rocks Renovations for Durham Region projects LA Rocks Renovations specifies the right product line for each surface and handles interior and exterior painting across Bowmanville, Clarington, and Durham Region.

The case for not picking a side

The conventional wisdom in paint comparisons is to declare a winner. After working through the specs, the pricing, and the field realities, that framing misses the point. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams are not competing for the same job on your walls. They are optimised differently, and the homeowners who get the best results are the ones who treat them as complementary tools rather than rivals.

What gets overlooked in most comparisons is the role of the tinting system. Both brands have invested heavily in their colour formulation, and the colours are calibrated to their own pigment bases. When you buy a Benjamin Moore colour in a Sherwin-Williams base — or vice versa through a spectrophotometer match — you are getting an approximation, not the original. For most colours, that approximation is close enough. For complex, warm-toned neutrals or deep saturated shades, it can drift noticeably. Staying within the brand’s own system for a specific colour is a detail that most guides skip over, and it is one of the more common sources of disappointment when a colour “doesn’t look right” after painting.

The other underrated factor is cure time. Homeowners focus on dry time because that is what they feel. Cure time is what actually determines whether the surface will hold up to cleaning, door contact, and daily use. Benjamin Moore Advance’s 30-day cure window is not a flaw — it is the trade-off for a finish that is genuinely hard and washable. Knowing that up front changes how you schedule a kitchen or cabinet project entirely.

Professional painting in Durham Region by LA Rocks Renovations

Choosing the right paint line is only part of the job. The prep work, application technique, and product knowledge that go into a professional finish are what separate a result that lasts from one that needs redoing in three years.

LA Rocks Renovations offers interior painting and exterior painting services across Bowmanville, Clarington, Newcastle, and the broader Durham Region. The team handles colour consultation, product specification, trim and cabinetry finishes, and full-house repaints — using the right product line for each surface, not just whatever is on hand. Whether you are refreshing a single room or repainting an entire home before a sale, LA Rocks Renovations delivers a clean, durable finish with clear communication from quote to completion. Contact LA Rocks Renovations for a free on-site estimate and get a specific product recommendation for your project before you spend a dollar on paint.

Useful sources

These references support the coverage figures, VOC data, and product comparisons in this article. Consult manufacturer spec sheets and your local dealer for final purchase decisions, as Canadian pricing and product availability can differ from published US data.

  • Consumer Reports — Best interior paints: Independent lab testing on interior paint performance by product line.
  • Paint Colour HQ — Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore complete comparison: Detailed side-by-side on solids content, colour range, pricing, and workability.
  • Soho Painters — Is Benjamin Moore paint good?: Professional painter’s assessment of Benjamin Moore lines including Advance cure time data.
  • Minimal and Modern — Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams ultimate guide: Contractor and DIY perspective on brand preferences by application type.
  • Pro Chicago Painters — Benjamin Moore vs Sherwin-Williams: Pricing analysis and promotional cadence comparison between the two brands.
  • EPA — VOCs and indoor air quality: Reference thresholds for low-VOC classification in architectural coatings.
  • Canadian VOC Concentration Limits Regulations (SOR/2009-264): Federal Canadian regulations governing VOC limits in architectural coatings.
  • Green Seal GS-11 Standard — Paints and Coatings: Third-party certification standard for low-VOC and environmentally responsible paints.
Back to blog